The Gristle

A Matter of Equity

Wednesday, August 24, 2016

A Matter of Equity: In the fierce cyclonic thunderstorm of a heated petroleum industry, there is perhaps an eye of calm and equilibrium.

Whatcom County was scheduled to appear in Olympia this week to defend against what might’ve been the largest property tax reassessment in county history, a proposed 50 percent devaluation of arguably the most important asset to the county’s property tax portfolio. Instead, the county settled last week with the BP Oil Refinery at Cherry Point, avoiding an appearance before the Washington State Board of Tax Appeals.

The settlement agreement reduces the assessed valuation of the refinery’s property and assets at Cherry Point by about 18 percent; but immediately frees up about $4.8 million in property taxes that have been held as valuation-in-controversy, according to Whatcom County Assessor Keith Willnauer. In addition, the agreement may also free up receipts held in controversy by ConocoPhillips. Concoco had withheld these payments in protest pending BP’s resolution with the county. Now that BP has settled, perhaps Conoco will, too.

“We were coming down to the wire,” Willnauer admitted, “but we were fully prepared for arguments, ready to make our case.

“When there is a threshold of highly disputed value, there is a statute that requires that we hold what is in dispute from valuation-in-controversy out from ordinary collections,” he said. “And in this case we have been holding a disputed $700 million in valuation for more than two years. The taxes have been being duly collected, while another $300-to-$400 million has been valuation-in-controversy, and has been held out of collections.”

The BP and Conoco refineries at Cherry Point are the number one and number two contributors to property tax receipts in Whatcom County, BP at nearly twice the contribution of Conoco. The amount paid into county taxing districts varies by kind—the refineries contribute about 3 percent to the county’s overall tax base; for the Blaine School District, the contribution is about 22 percent of the tax base; for Fire District 7, it’s a third—33 percent of property tax revenues collected for the district, according to the Assessor’s office. BP paid about $10 million per year into these local taxing districts. Now, as a result of the settlement, BP will pay about $1.2 million per year less in property tax.

The settlement has little to do with county policy discussions currently underway regarding the future of fuels export at Cherry Point, except perhaps in two aspects: First, the broadly understood importance of such industries to the health of the county’s tax base. Second, an indicator of just how much in flux the energy business is in the United States: Refineries have operated at Cherry Point under varying ownerships for half a century without a whimper about the taxes they pay.

What this means in the short term is homeowners will see a slight reduction in their tax rates as the county gains access to taxes held in protest by the refineries and is able to backfill about three years of revenue from disputed valuation. In out years, it means the refineries will contribute a little bit less to the health and prosperity of Whatcom County, and that means homeowners must contribute more to maintain current levels of service.

“When you’ve already levied to a certain amount and are faced with potentially a large refund, that can affect the year’s tax rolls from property tax. Levy rates can go up considerably to fill that hole,” Willnauer explained. “Property tax statutes allow you to recover that refund in a subsequent year; however, if districts don’t have that kind of reserves, then those tax rolls are affected.

“The result,” he summed up, “is that we have stipulated to a value than was less than what we had on the books originally, but considerably more than the amount that was being held in controversy.

“We now have an opportunity to recover what had already been pushed on to other taxpayers.”

The dust-up began in 2013, when BP announced the sale of its Carson, Calif., refinery and related logistics and marketing assets in the region to Tesoro Corporation for approximately $2.4 billion as part of a plan to reshape BP’s fuels business. Cash proceeds from the sale included approximately $1.075 billion for assets and an estimated $1.35 billion primarily for inventory at market value and other working capital.

The sale was perhaps not the windfall BP desired in a volatile energy market, but the sale did set the floor for what a refinery might be worth, triggering an attempt by the energy giant to claim the valuation of its Cherry Point refinery assets should be sliced by more than 50 percent. There are problems with BP Corporate’s reasoning—namely that the Cherry Point refinery had recently received significant upgrades as part of the company’s shift in operations and the opening of international markets for export fuels. Indeed, they’d dumped the aging Carson facility precisely for the cash flow and nimbleness they’d require for that transition. Now BP was trying to argue that what they’d dumped in a fire sale in California set the price for the value of what they’d improved in the hottest section of real estate in the burgeoning energy export market—the deep water at Cherry Point, Washington.

The county found BP’s arguments that the valuation of their Cherry Point assets should be revised downward to roughly equivalent to what the company’d just invested in improving those assets for future profitability… unpersuasive. But the county was willing to consider that the valuation might be equitably adjusted, particularly when the risk included protracted attorney fees and legal battles fought in front of the mercurial Board of Tax Appeals in Olympia.

“The system goes back to stable, the amounts we plan on receiving becomes stable, the tax administration itself can move forward, and we get to move ahead without the damaging effects of valuation controversy,” Willnauer said. “And in fact the taxing district recovered quite a bit of substantial value that had been removed previously as we responded to the controversy.”

Skagit-Wynonna
Past Columns
A Creeping Paralysis

October 18, 2017

Fire and Water

October 11, 2017

Blockadia

September 27, 2017

Ounce of Prevention

September 20, 2017

Dwelling On It

September 13, 2017

Keeping the Dream Alive

September 6, 2017

A Bridge Too Far?

August 23, 2017

The Missing Middle

August 16, 2017

The Last, Best Solution

August 9, 2017

Fire and Water III

August 2, 2017

Fire and Water II

July 26, 2017

Fire and Water

July 19, 2017

Some Assembly Required

July 12, 2017

Good, Bad, Ugly

July 5, 2017

Zero Hour

June 28, 2017

Standoff

June 21, 2017

An Existential Triangle

June 14, 2017

Divided Decisions

June 7, 2017

Events
Today
Book Group Mixers

5:30pm|Village Books

Bringing history into sharp focus

10:00am

Fall Craft & Antique Show

10:00am|Northwest Washington Fairgrounds

U.S. Citizenship Class

6:00pm|Lynden Library

3MB

7:00pm|Sylvia Center for the Arts

The Women of Lockerbie

7:00pm|Lynden Christian High School

Balkan Folk Dance

7:00pm|Fairhaven Library

Summer Bike Stories

7:00pm|Cafe Velo

Young Frankenstein

7:30pm|Anacortes Community Theatre

Trove
Tomorrow
Fall Craft & Antique Show

10:00am|Northwest Washington Fairgrounds

3MB

7:00pm|Sylvia Center for the Arts

The Women of Lockerbie

7:00pm|Lynden Christian High School

Young Frankenstein

7:30pm|Anacortes Community Theatre

Wild Things

9:30am|Stimpson Family Nature Reserve

Book and Bake Sale

10:00am|Lynden Library

Grand Opening and Open House

11:00am|Social Fabric

Books and Bites

1:00pm|Blaine Library

Clean Eating

2:00pm|Cordata Community Food Co-op

Coffee Tasting

3:00pm|Camber Cafe

Food Not Bombs

4:00pm|downtown Bellingham

Art Night

5:00pm|SpringHill Suites by Marriott

12 Minutes Max Auditions

5:00pm|Firehouse Performing Arts Center

Amber Sky CD Release Party

6:00pm|Presence Studio

Gore & Lore Tours

6:00pm|Historic Fairhaven, downtown Bellingham

Falliday Vintage Market

6:00pm|Port Transit Event Center

Family Story Night

6:00pm|Fairhaven Library

Wild & Scenic Film Festival

6:30pm|Lincoln Theatre

Poetry Party

7:00pm|Mount Baker Theatre

Upstream

7:00pm|Village Books

USA Dance

7:00pm|Majestic

Thriller Dance Class

7:00pm|Moles Farewell Tributes

Halloween Movie Night

7:00pm|BHS Performing Arts Center

Friday Night Flicks

7:30pm|Van Zandt Community Hall

Sanford-Hill Piano Series

7:30pm|Performing Arts Center

Hellingham

8:00pm|Upfront Theatre

Holding the Light

8:00pm|Honey Moon

Trove Village Books
Saturday
Fall Craft & Antique Show

10:00am|Northwest Washington Fairgrounds

3MB

7:00pm|Sylvia Center for the Arts

The Women of Lockerbie

7:00pm|Lynden Christian High School

Young Frankenstein

7:30pm|Anacortes Community Theatre

Book and Bake Sale

10:00am|Lynden Library

Falliday Vintage Market

6:00pm|Port Transit Event Center

Gore & Lore Tours

6:00pm|Historic Fairhaven, downtown Bellingham

Hellingham

8:00pm|Upfront Theatre

Lynden Breakfast

8:00am|VFW Hall

Harvest Happens

8:00am|Bellewood Acres

Ferndale Breakfast

8:00am|Ferndale Senior Center

NSEA Work Party

9:00am|Terrell Creek

Anacortes Farmers Market

9:00am|Depot Arts Center

Pumpkin Patch on Rails

9:00am|Wickersham Station

Pumpkins 4 Pajamas

9:00am|Lakeway Fred Meyer

Scarecrow Stuffing Contest

9:00am|Garden Spot Nursery

Twin Sisters Farmers Market

9:00am|North Fork Library, Nugents Corner

Landscape stewards work party

9:00am|Chuckanut Center

Port race ponders a wasted waterfront

9:30am

Fall Family Fun

10:00am|Glen Echo Garden

Bellingham Comicon

10:00am|Ferndale Event Center

Bellingham Farmers Market

10:00am|Depot Market Square

Everyday Superheroes 5K

10:00am|Squalicum Creek Park

Blaine Gardeners Market

10:00am|H Street Plaza

98221 Studio Tour

10:00am|Fidalgo Island

Blaine Oktoberfest

10:00am|Blaine

Community Cider Pressing

10:00am|Chuckanut Center

Correspondence Club

10:30am|Mindport Exhibits

Enlightened Caterpillar

10:30am|Village Books

Crown Jewel Wilderness

11:00am|Western Washington University Bookstore

Holiday Gifts from the Kitchen

11:00am|Community Food Co-op

Mushrooms gone wild

12:00pm

Conquering Writer's BLock

1:00pm|Blaine Library

Fidalgo Youth Symphony

1:00pm|McIntyre Hall

Winter Birds of Whatcom County

2:00pm|Ferndale Library

Undersea Bubble Fantasia

2:30pm|Mount Baker Theatre

Brew on the Slough

5:00pm|Maple Hall

Community Library Celebration

5:00pm|North Fork Library

Bellingham Hoptoberfest

6:00pm|Bellingham Sportsplex

Seeds of Change

6:30pm|Edison Granary

The Great Unconformity

7:00pm|Village Books

Whose Live Anyway?

7:30pm|Performing Arts Center Concert Hall

Skagit Symphony's Gala Concert

7:30pm|McIntyre Hall

The Tannahill Weavers

7:30pm|Littlefield Celtic Center

Original Comedy Night

8:00pm|Lincoln Theatre

see our complete calendar »

CWWarrenMiller Trove Mt. Baker Theatre Undersea Bubble Village Books Bellingham Farmer’s Market Cascadia Weekly Subscribe Ad 1