The Gristle

A Supreme Shifting

Wednesday, June 27, 2018

A SUPREME SHIFTING: Elections have consequences; and a matter considered settled in Washington must now receive additional review.

The Supreme Court of the United States this week returned the 2017 case of Arlene’s Flowers back to their state counterpart in Washington. In its Feb. 16, 2017 decision, the Washington State Supreme Court unanimously upheld a lower court decision that a florist had clearly violated the state’s nondiscrimination law by refusing to provide floral arrangements to a gay couple because of the owner’s personal beliefs.

A deeply divided U.S. Supreme Court had earlier this month come to a more ambivalent conclusion in their Masterpiece Cakeshop ruling, an analogous case in which a baker in Colorado had refused service to a gay couple on religious grounds. Justices found the baker had a right to do so, but their decision was deemed a “narrow” one, specific to this single instance, and in which justices declined to frame overarching considerations.

As Justice Anthony Kennedy, the author of some of the court’s most important gay-rights rulings, outlined in the majority opinion, the case involved a collision between two important principles. On the one hand, society has recognized that “gay persons and gay couples cannot be treated as social outcasts or as inferior in dignity and worth,” and their rights are protected by the Constitution. On the other hand, “the religious and philosophical objections to gay marriage are protected views and in some instances protected forms of expression.”

In short, where do the rights of a private business to refuse service end; and where do class protections against state-sanctioned religious bigotry begin? Justices declined to tackle those questions.

SCOTUS dodged the larger, lasting considerations, perhaps out of a humble awareness that American society is quickly—very quickly—becoming at ease with same-sex marriage; and the violent hatred of the union by religious groups is being swept into the moldy dustbin of history. Why make durable law around a resistance growing quickly irrelevant?

Washington’s jurisprudence is clearer. Under state law, a business need not provide a particular service, but if it chooses to do so for couples of the opposite sex, it must provide that service equally to same-sex couples.

Washington is one of 20 states that provide clear protections against discrimination in employment, housing and public accommodations on the basis of both sexual orientation and gender identity.

As is common when cases involving similar issues as a recent ruling are pending before the court, the U.S. Supreme Court formally vacates the lower court ruling and sends the case back to the lower court for a second look. The lower court then reevaluates the case in light of the new ruling, and determines whether that new ruling impacts the case.

“We expected this procedural step,” Washington’s Attorney General Bob Ferguson said. “The Washington State Supreme Court now has the job of determining whether the U.S. Supreme Court ruling affects this case. I am confident they will come to the same conclusion they did in their previous, unanimous ruling upholding the civil rights of same-sex couples in our state.”

“The Supreme Court has simply asked the lower court to take another look at this case in light of their recent decision in Masterpiece, but they did not indicate there was anything wrong with the ruling,” agreed Sarah Warbelow, legal director of the Human Rights Campaign, the nation’s largest lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer civil rights organization. “In Masterpiece, the Supreme Court found that the state of Colorado’s enforcement of its civil rights law was flawed due to perceived bias in the process, however, there is no indication that there were flaws in the application of civil rights law in Arlene’s Flowers. We view this decision as encouraging news that justice will prevail and the Washington State Supreme Court will again uphold the state’s nondiscrimination laws ensuring LGBTQ people cannot be turned away from a business open to the public.”

The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision on Masterpiece and other recent rulings (including this week’s uphold of the Trump administration’s third attempt at a bigotry-laced travel ban based on specious national security concerns) is a cautionary illustration of the knife edge upon which the high court rests, with no opinion in firm majority and fluid allegiances of opinion among justices. But clearly the potential is fatally proximate for President Donald Trump to upend the detente of slim majorities with lifetime appointments to the high court. The consequences of those appointments would long, long outlast his presidency.

The Gristle has noted the searing pace of lifetime appointments at all levels of the federal court by the Trump administration—a court-packing that has outstripped in ferocity that of any previous president in this past century. Federal courts hold the power to slow, check or overturn any number of political or legislative achievements, particularly in eras of partisan gridlock and administrative paralysis. Of course, none hold more power than the Supreme Court, which can in a very brief period weld in place our civil and social discourse for a century.

A decision by the Court that money is speech and corporations are people has transformed the political and economic landscape of the United States in fewer than 20 years. A decision by the Court to ignore one clause and section of the Constitution to favor another has triggered the explosion of guns and attendant gun violence in roughly the same period. In one week, this week, in other rulings SCOTUS has with the slimmest of majorities upheld racial gerrymandering and set back women’s reproductive freedoms.

The remedy to the pace of judicial overreach by the president lies in the confirmation of these appointments by the U.S. Senate, which itself stands on the knife-edge of falling to the opposition (and, in our system of government, the braking) party this fall.

Elections have consequences. Midterms matter.

Past Columns
Trust Is Reciprocal

July 18, 2018

Pressure in the Bottle

July 11, 2018

Sharing the Pain

July 4, 2018

The Costs of Failure

June 6, 2018

Thumb on the Scales

May 30, 2018

Bungle in the Jungle?

May 23, 2018

Heating Up

May 16, 2018

Home Run

May 9, 2018

State of the County

May 2, 2018

Symptoms of Pain

April 25, 2018

A Last Ditch Effort

April 18, 2018

Much ADUs About Nothing

April 11, 2018

The Sin of Sinclair

April 4, 2018

All Thumbs on the Scale

March 28, 2018

The Boundaries Between Us

March 21, 2018

Dirty Deeds

March 7, 2018

Sunshine Storm

February 28, 2018

Events
Today
Boating Center Open

10:00am|Community Boating Center

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Bard on the Beach

12:00pm|Vanier Park

Northwest Raspberry Festival

10:00am|Lynden

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Sin & Gin Tours

7:00pm|Downtown Bellingham, historic Fairhaven

Summer of Blood

7:00pm|Rexville Grange Amphitheater

LOL-apalooza

9:00pm|Upfront Theatre

Raspberry Pancake Breakfast

7:00am|Lynden Community Center

Tour de Whatcom

7:30am|Boundary Bay Brewery

Ferndale Breakfast

8:00am|Ferndale Senior Center

Anacortes Farmers Market

9:00am|Depot Arts Center

Mount Vernon Farmers Market

9:00am|Riverwalk Park

Christmas in July Bazaar

9:00am|Bellingham Masonic Center

Twin Sisters Market

9:00am|Nugent's Corner, North Fork Library

Four Democrats seek election in the Skagit

9:00am

Primary Election Forum

9:30am|Bellingham High School

NW Art Beat Studio Tour

10:00am|Skagit County

Blaine Gardeners Market

10:00am|H Street Plaza

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Summer Seersucker Bicycle Ride

10:00am|Gilkey Square

Lynden Farmers Market

10:00am|Centennial Park

Lummi Island Saturday Market

10:00am|Islander Grocery Store

Bellingham Farmers Market

10:00am| Depot Market Square

Correspondence Club

10:30am|Mindport Exhibits

Downtown Market Walk

11:00am|Downtown Bellingham

Street Food Saturdays

11:00am|Zuanich Point Park

Show & Shine

11:00am|BelleWood Acres

Hot Ticket

11:00am|North Fork Library

Public Sail

12:00pm|Cap Sante Marina

The Nandia Trilogy

1:00pm|Barnes & Noble

Craftapalooza

1:00pm|Point Roberts Library

Concrete Saturday Market

1:00pm|Concrete Community Center

Field Games

1:00pm|VanderYacht Park

Wren and Della

1:00pm|Blaine Library

Lynden Cemetery Tour

1:00pm|Lynden Cemetery

State Street History Tour

1:30pm|Depot Market Square

The Secret Garden

3:00pm|Mount Baker Theatre

Ferndale Uncorked and Uncapped

3:00pm|Centennial Riverwalk Park

Nooksack River Walk

3:00pm|Horseshoe Bend Trailhead

Whatcom Democrats Country Picnic

4:00pm|Hovander Homestead Park

Seafood Boil

5:30pm|Semiahmoo Resort

Seafood Boil

5:30pm|Semiahmoo Resort

Feast and Frolic

5:30pm|Viva Farms

Saturday Seafood Boil

5:30pm|Semiahmoo Resort

Music at Maritime

6:00pm|Maritime Heritage Park

Austin Jenckes

7:00pm|Eagle Haven Winery

Bellingham Youth Jazz Band

7:00pm|Bellingham Senior Activity Center

Sin & Gin Tours

7:00pm|Downtown Bellingham, historic Fairhaven

Nelson Mandela Tribute Concert

7:30pm|Bellingham Unitarian Fellowship

Bebel Gilberto

7:30pm| Lincoln Theatre

Gerrymandering Update

7:30pm|Island Library

Cascadia Weekly Subscribe Ad 1
Tomorrow
Boating Center Open

10:00am|Community Boating Center

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Bard on the Beach

12:00pm|Vanier Park

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Summer of Blood

7:00pm|Rexville Grange Amphitheater

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

NW Art Beat Studio Tour

10:00am|Skagit County

Sin & Gin Tours

7:00pm|Downtown Bellingham, historic Fairhaven

Rabbit Ride

8:00am|Fairhaven Bicycle

Vietnam Veterans Car Show

10:00am|Barkley Village

Edison Farmers Market

10:00am|Edison Granary

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Langar in Lynden

11:00am|Guru Nanak Gursikh Gurdwara

La Conner Live!

1:00pm|Gilkey Square

Skulls and Skins

1:00pm|Tennant Lake

Mosaic Stepping Stone Workshop

1:00pm|Chuckanut Center

Audubon at the Museum

1:30pm|Whatcom Museum's Old City Hall

Fiddlin' Fox Summer Concerts

2:00pm|Fairhaven Village Green

Trivia Time

3:30pm|Boundary Bay Brewery

Trivia Time

3:30pm|Boundary Bay Brewery

Cascadia Weekly Subscribe Ad 1 2018 Cascadia Kids
Monday
Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Boating Center Open

10:00am|Community Boating Center

Bard on the Beach

12:00pm|Vanier Park

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Rainbow Reads

12:00pm|Ferndale Library

Plant Diagnostic Clinics

5:00pm|Bellingham Public Library

Paddling Whatcom County

6:00pm|REI

Cuban Salsa

6:00pm|Bell Tower Studios

Books on Tap Two

6:30pm|Tino's Pizza & Pasta Co.

Guffawingham

9:00pm|Firefly Lounge

see our complete calendar »

Cascadia Weekly Subscribe Ad 1 2018 Cascadia Kids Trove Web Village Books