The Gristle

Fire and Frost

Wednesday, August 14, 2019

FIRE AND FROST: The most remarkable outcome of last week’s local election was, of course, the astonishing performance of Seth Fleetwood for mayor of Bellingham.

Let’s be clear: Seth was always the safe, reliable bet to come through the Top-Two primary in first or second place; but by the Gristle’s jaundiced eye he performed six points above forecast. His matchup against April Barker, who arrived in the second slot, promises a very dynamic and intelligent policy discussion through the fall.

Why did Seth perform so well? We’ll argue (without intending to take an atom away from this celebrated and familiar native son), it was in part because dark horse Garrett O’Brien performed poorly. O’Brien, by our forecast, should have picked up a leading 30 percent of the vote; instead, he arrived in last place behind Pinky Vargas.

A deeper dive into more accurate data than what was available on election night perhaps tells the story. At nearly 40 percent, Whatcom’s turnout for this election was one of the highest in the state, and certainly the highest in populous counties around Puget Sound. Likely it is a fairly reliable barometer of outcomes we may expect in November.

Tony Larson collected about 4,400 votes in Bellingham precincts in his bid for Whatcom County Executive. O’Brien received 5,073 votes in the Bellingham mayoral race. Each are about 20 percent of the roughly 23,400 total votes cast in each race—a good apples-to-apples comparison.

Why would a vote for Tony match a vote for Garrett? Their campaigns each offered a private-sector alternative to a slate of government insiders, and appealed to a particular demographic eager to “Throw the Rascals Out.” They both held strong credentials in the FIRE lobby—finance, business, construction industry and real estate. They both promised to throttle government regulations and promote growth.

Larson’s performance in Bellingham precincts eerily paces support for Donald Trump in 2016, and that support is also matched in countywide ballots for Larson at around 38 percent. That’s an important number in Whatcom County politics—it’s essentially the dimensions of hardcore, always-dependable Republican votes. That’s the size of Trump Country.

But Bellingham is not Trump Country. Only 20 percent of the city voted for Trump in 2016, and that appears to be the ceiling for appeals to that particular demographic in the City of Subdued Excitement.

The forecast model was wrong.

But Garrett outperformed Tony by nearly 700 votes in Bellingham, which suggests his appeal was broader overall—and he did present himself as an extremely charismatic and likable new face in local politics.

We’ll make the case that Seth—long a familiar and calming and stabilizing voice in local politics—may have also picked up a lot of secondary votes as the alternative choice to other candidates’ higher perceived negatives. Certainly, a candidate with a boldly stated platform and agenda like April Barker has picked up some negatives along with the positives in her journey. O’Brien was mostly a cypher on local issues; but with Fleetwood you knew where he stood, and it was nearly always in a good and thoughtful place. He was the safe, secure bet for Bellingham’s future.

Barker, as we mentioned, stands out as having a boldly articulated campaign. She runs on a platform of social justice reform, with a laser focus on affordable housing. These positions undoubtedly underscore her support, and the reason she arrived in the second slot in the general election.

There is a reason April is running; and in politics a stated clarity of purpose is remarkable.

We give April credit for campaigning on specific issues that face the city, and her voice continuing into the fall is an important one. There are tangible things she wants to accomplish through the mayor’s office. Her directness is refreshing.

Because she is running on issues with quite a bit of controversy and heat that undergird them, we’ll speculate that April’s negatives—the reasons a voter might prefer someone else in office—going into the general election are higher than Seth’s.

Theirs is an interesting inversion.

A former City Council member, Seth has been out of government policymaking for sufficient time that he is plausibly an outsider to those issues. Whatever problems exist, he was not part of the making of them; and he could be critical of them. He’s not. His message is a positive, affirmative one—that the city has made great strides, and needs to continue its stride.

April, currently serving on City Council, is an outspoken critic of city directions. Her position is that the city has been on the wrong track for a number of years, and needs to take aggressive steps toward a more inclusive, pluralistic future. Yet those years also equal her span on Council, and are measured in the number of votes she has delivered 7-0 with the Council majority. Arguably, the immediacy of her term on City Council has given her insight into administrative weaknesses and areas that need attention.

Seth, the outsider, is running as the consummate insider—the youthful spirit with deep roots everyone expected would one day be mayor. April, the insider, is running as an outsider—promising to shake things up and make Bellingham a better place.

April is specific. Seth is not, and is by nature and approach an accommodating generalist. She can be sharp-tongued and direct; whereas he is soft-spoken and circumspect.

She is fire. He is frost.

It’s a terrific throwdown in style and delivery.

Past Columns
‘I Have A Dream’

January 15, 2020

Olympia Olympics

January 8, 2020

What Dreams May Come

January 1, 2020


December 25, 2019

Missing Middle

December 18, 2019

War Waged on Two Fronts

December 11, 2019

Work Horse, Not Show Horse

December 4, 2019

Toward A Housing Summit

November 27, 2019

Dueling Data

November 20, 2019

Of Apples and Barrels

November 13, 2019

Hide the Money

October 30, 2019

Anchors Are Weighed

October 23, 2019

A Working Waterfront?

October 15, 2019

Keep Working

October 9, 2019

Signs of Hate

October 2, 2019

Trust Gap

September 25, 2019

Netse Mot

September 18, 2019

A Rising Tide

September 11, 2019

The Power of Change

September 4, 2019

Hands Against Hate

August 28, 2019

A Forest of Words Poetry Competition

10:00am|Whatcom County

Deep Forest Experience

11:00am|Rockport State Park

Paddling With Spirits


The Curious Savage

7:00pm|Alger Community Church

Beauty and the Beast

7:00pm|BAAY Theater

Contest of Crowns

7:30pm|ACT Annex

The Revolutionists

7:30pm|Sylvia Center for the Arts

Space Trek

7:30pm|Upfront Theatre

Pancake Breakfast

8:00am|Ferndale Senior Center

Martin Luther King, Jr. Human Rights Conference

8:30am|Whatcom Community College

WNPS Field Trip

9:00am|Larrabee Park

Gluten- and Dairy-Free Cooking

10:00am|Blaine Library

Skagit Eagle Festival


Winter Farmers Market

10:00am|Depot Market Square

Your Life is a Story Writers Group

10:30am|South Whatcom Library

Deep Forest Experience

11:00am|Rockport State Park

Womxn's March

11:00am|Bellingham City Hall

Propagating Perennials

11:00am|Christianson's Nursery

Seed Swap, Barter Fair and Skillshare

12:00pm|Bellingham Unitarian Fellowship

Camera Unobscura Workshop

1:00pm|Whatcom Museum's Lightcatcher Building

More than a label


Bird Smarts

2:00pm|Everson Library

Discovering Sherry Tasting

2:00pm| Seifert & Jones Wine Merchants

Rising Above the Pain

4:00pm|Village Books

Sunrise Night of Music

6:00pm|Maple Hall

Blue Abode Comedy Showcase

7:00pm|Blue Abode Bar

Patsy Cline Tribute Concert

7:00pm|Magnolia Grill Hall

Hot Club of Troy

7:00pm|Walton Theatre

Whatcom Wind Ensemble Winter Concert

7:00pm|Performing Arts Center Concert Hall

Space Trek

7:30pm|Upfront Theatre

Salsa Night

9:30pm|Cafe Rumba

A Forest of Words Poetry Competition

10:00am|Whatcom County

Deep Forest Experience

11:00am|Rockport State Park

Beauty and the Beast

7:00pm|BAAY Theater

The Curious Savage

7:00pm|Alger Community Church

Skagit Eagle Festival


Deep Forest Experience

11:00am|Rockport State Park

Space Trek

7:30pm|Upfront Theatre

Sedro-Woolley Community Breakfast

8:00am|American Legion Post #43

Skagit Eagle Festival


Deep Forest Experience

11:00am|Rockport State Park

Langar in Lynden

11:00am| Guru Nanak Gursikh Gurdwara

Birding for Kids


An American in Paris

7:30pm|Mount Baker Theatre

An American in Paris


Deep Forest Experience

11:00am|Rockport State Park

Skagit Eagle Festival


Deep Forest Experience

11:00am|Rockport State Park

Birding for Kids


MLK Day Work Party

9:00am|Barr Creek

MLK Day of Service Work Party

10:00am|Whatcom Creek

Martin Luther King, Jr. Day Read-In

10:00am|Village Books

Martin Luther King, Jr. Community Celebration

12:00pm|Mount Baker Theatre

Teen Art Club

3:00pm|Blaine Library

Community Soup Kitchen

6:00pm|Little Cheerful Cafe

Cider U

6:30pm|Thousand Acre Cider House


7:00pm|Alternative Library

Martin Luther King, Jr. Day event

7:00pm|Bellingham Unitarian Fellowship


9:00pm|Firefly Lounge

see our complete calendar »