The Gristle

‘Alternative Methods’

Wednesday, January 9, 2019

‘ALTERNATIVE METHODS’: After nearly 30 years of intransigence, Whatcom County has finally come into compliance with the Washington State Growth Management Act of 1990—by essentially running out the clock on citizen challenges to the inadequacy of county planning on growth.

In the quiet lull of the holidays, the Western Washington Growth Management Hearings Board closed the outstanding challenge of the Hirst petition that the county was failing to plan growth in tandem with adequate resources for growth. The essentials of the Hirst complaint remain relevant (and will undoubtedly plague the county for generations); a decision of the Legislature last session simply renders those complaints moot.

In 2016, the Washington State Supreme Court agreed with the findings of the state growth board that “the county’s Comprehensive Plan does not satisfy the GMA requirements to protect water availability or water quality,” noting “it is the local government—and not the state Dept. of Ecology—that is responsible to make the decision on water adequacy as part of its land use decision.” Responsibility for planning, of course, is the flip side of local control and authority over planning.

The assertion, however, held profound consequences for other counties and jurisdictions around the state that had relied on Ecology as their authority in determining adequate water supply to issue building permits, a requirement of GMA. These counties called on their state representatives to issue a “fix” that would bring the state agency back into a partnership role in determining supply.

In response to the Supreme Court’s decision, the 2018 Legislature adopted ESSB 6091. The law authorizes Ecology to work with specified local jurisdictions, watershed planning units and federally recognized Indian tribes to review and update various watershed plans to identify, among other things, impacts of permit-exempt wells on groundwater supplies.

Importantly, ESSB 6091 does nothing to resolve the actual underlying argument of the Hirst complaint, that using Ecology’s established rules Whatcom County had oversubscribed its water supply in numerous river basins along the northern tier. The Nooksack River drainage encompasses the bulk of Whatcom County and is designated by the state as WRIA-1.

As the hearings board dryly commented, “The amendments included in ESSB 6091 provided alternative methods for achieving compliance with [GMA], the provision which requires counties to adopt comprehensive plan rural element measures to protect surface water and groundwater resources.”

The law does require Whatcom County to adopt an updated watershed plan for WRIA-1 by February of this year.

Whatcom County Council received a status report on the work of the WRIA-1 Planning Unit in a special session this week that reported on the WWGMHB finding of compliance, as revised by the Legislature’s “fix.”

In the report, Council learned the Planning Unit was unlikely to achieve consensus by the deadline imposed by ESSB 6091, and were instead advised to send an index of work that has been completed along with a letter to Ecology explaining the impasse. This is not at all surprising, considering the diverse and often fractious Planning Unit is not a unit, and to a large degree many of its citizen members do not plan and indeed are hostile to planning.

The scope of work required under ESSB 6091 is narrow, and concerns primarily how the county will mitigate or offset the impacts of a projected 2,100 additional wells in those impaired basins over the next 20-year planning window.

Even here, after a year, the Planning Unit was unable to reach consensus—arguing over whether wells should be metered, and if metered whether that should be voluntary; grousing over the fee, if any, to permit new wells; and in particular quarreling over the volume of water each of these wells might draw. These are fairly straightforward questions, once you have acknowledged water supply is oversubscribed. But, of course, there is no agreement on that point, either.

“We’ve had a very challenging process placed in front of us since last February when the state enacted legislation,” County Executive Jack Louws summarized, adding that he was pleased they did it because the decision allowed the county to move forward on a number of permitting issues.

“It’s been very clear from the start that it would be difficult to get the initiating governments—that is, the tribes, the City of Bellingham, Public Utility District, and Whatcom County—and the Planning Unit to come together on a unanimous consensus on a very contentious issue related to water rights.

“My sense is that the initiating governments themselves were not going to come to consensus on all of the issues” by the deadline, he admitted, let alone the Planning Unit.

Of course, all of this comes down to the responsible government under GMA—the county—deferring and delaying the hard decisions about planning, for which the county is held by the state as having ultimate authority.

In their preamble to the 1990 law, the Legislature sketched the challenges of GMA: “Uncoordinated and unplanned growth, together with a lack of common goals expressing the public’s interest in the conservation and the wise use of our lands, pose a threat to the environment, sustainable economic development, and the health, safety and high quality of life enjoyed by residents of this state.”

Former County Council member Carl Weimer steadfastly believed years of noncompliance with the spirit of these goals might have been avoided if county planners and policymakers had simply sat down with petitioners and tried to address their finite and reasonable concerns.

“There is a huge difference,” he commented from a distance on the recent order, “between being legally compliant with an Act and embracing the vision and spirit of it.”

Past Columns
Thin Green Line

June 26, 2019

A Journeyman’s Journey

June 12, 2019

Her Story

June 5, 2019

Do Overs

May 29, 2019

E Pluribus Unum

May 15, 2019

The Millworks

May 8, 2019

State of the County

May 1, 2019

A Change in Climate

April 24, 2019

The Raucous Caucus

April 17, 2019


April 10, 2019

Edge City

April 3, 2019

Fixing the Fix

March 27, 2019

Halfway Houses

March 20, 2019

New Directions

March 13, 2019

Fire and Ice

March 6, 2019

The Big Short

February 27, 2019

Marina Lacuna

February 20, 2019

New Bites at the Apple

February 13, 2019

Coal Folds

February 6, 2019

Community Boating Center Open

10:00am|Community Boating Center

Bard on the Beach

4:00pm|Vanier Park

Scrubs Camp

8:30am|Bellingham Technical College

Perspectives from the Port

11:30am| Northwood Hall

Wellness Wednesdays

12:00pm|Skagit Riverwalk Plaza

Wednesday Farmers Market

2:00pm|Barkley Village Green

Sedro-Woolley Farmers Market

3:00pm|Hammer Heritage Square

Group Run

6:00pm|Skagit Running Company

Backdoor to Baker

6:30pm|Prime Sports Institute

Brewers Cruise

6:30pm|Bellingham Cruise Terminal

Thomas Harris and Kevin Woods Quintet

7:00pm|Sylvia Center for the Arts

Summer Funny

9:00pm|Upfront Theatre

Trove Web
Community Boating Center Open

10:00am|Community Boating Center

Bard on the Beach

12:00pm|Vanier Park

English Country Dancing

1:30pm|Bellingham Senior Activity Center

Blues and Brews

5:00pm|Hotel Bellwether

Community Pint Night for Planned Parenthood


Fiction Writing Group

6:00pm|Village Books

Elizabeth Park Summer Concert Series

6:00pm|Elizabeth Park


6:00pm|Ciao Thyme

Joe and Carol Young

6:00pm|Chuckanut Center

Life Between the Pages Dinner Book Club

6:30pm|Evolve Chocolate + Cafe

Mediterranean Mezzes

6:30pm|Community Food Co-op

Balkan Folk Dancers

7:00pm|Fairhaven Library

James and the Giant Peach

7:30pm|Anacortes Community Theatre


7:30pm| Bellingham Theatre Guild

Good, Bad, Ugly

7:30pm|Upfront Theatre

House Concert with Yogoman and Bongo Jac

7:30pm|Chuckanut Center


7:30pm|Sylvia Center for the Arts

Support Vertical Trove Web
Community Boating Center Open

10:00am|Community Boating Center

Bard on the Beach

12:00pm|Vanier Park


7:30pm| Bellingham Theatre Guild

James and the Giant Peach

7:30pm|Anacortes Community Theatre

Wild Things

9:30am|Marine Park

Plover Ferry Rides

12:00pm|Blaine Harbor

Valley Writers

1:00pm|South Whatcom Library

Ferndale Farmers Market

2:00pm|1750 LaBounty Dr.

Peace Vigil

4:00pm|Downtown Bellingham

Fourth Friday Art Walk

5:00pm|Historic Fairhaven

Whatcom Cultural Arts Festival

5:00pm|Fairhaven Village Green

Orca Month Kayak Tour

5:30pm|Waypoint Park

Harper&I Dance presents Through the Decades

7:00pm|Mount Baker Theatre


7:30pm|Maritime Heritage Park

Writer's Block, PainProv

7:30pm|Upfront Theatre

Comedy Benefit for Mt. Baker Planned Parenthood

9:00pm|The Shakedown

see our complete calendar »

Trove Web Village Books Cascadia Weekly Subscribe Ad 1 Support Vertical