Wednesday, October 11, 2017

Changing the zoning in built-out neighborhoods to allow detached accessory dwelling units (what Kelly Bashaw and Dan Hammill called “backyard cottages and mother-in-law units over garages” in a recent column, “Schools and Planning for Growth”) is not the way to address Bellingham’s urgent need for affordable housing. And the debate over such a zoning change is being conducted in a way harmful to our community cohesion.

Not only would new detached accessory dwelling units likely be expensive to rent and dominated by vacation rentals (so they wouldn’t add significantly to affordable housing), but constructing these new units would tear apart the fabric of existing neighborhoods. Under the false-hope banner of increasing affordable housing, neighbors would be set up for conflict between those seeking additional income and their neighbors who would lose backyard sunlight, privacy, and predictability.

How many backyard vegetable gardens, decks, and play areas would lose hours of sunlight when new two-story structures pop up next door? Apartments over garages are typically constructed with outdoor staircases that are tenants’ only access to fresh air—so residents would understandably want to sit outside overlooking their neighbors’ yards.

Bellingham’s current zoning for single-family neighborhoods (more precisely “residential single zones”) protects current residents from these encroachments on sunlight, privacy, and predictability through a variety of rules. Protections include requirements for setbacks from property lines, limiting the buildable portion of a lot, prohibiting detached accessory dwelling units (unless “grandfathered” and legalized under a 1996 law), and regulating attached accessory dwelling units (including the requirement that one or the other unit be owner-occupied). Bellingham Municipal Code is available online (and is reader-friendly); most of these rules are in chapter 20.30 or 20.10.035. The Infill Housing chapter (20.28) that aims to create opportunities for more affordable housing by establishing special development regulations for nontraditional housing forms does not apply to residential single zones. Applying it to “residential single” is being discussed.

Conflict among Bellingham residents has already been flamed by proponents of changing accessory-dwelling-unit zoning—when they accuse current homeowners of lack of compassion for residents who cannot afford to buy a home in the current market. This echoes a long U.S. tradition of promoting conflict between people defending the sparse stability in their lives against those with greater need (for example employers who hired whites only, then during strikes hired non-white scabs).

I am concerned that a divide-and-conquer strategy is being employed whenever I hear remarks like “you people who bought houses a long time ago and don’t want the zoning changed are the reason why people like me can’t afford to buy a house,” or statements like this from the Bashaw-Hammill column:

“To us, housing is an equity and fairness issue. By not allowing people access to different housing types like townhouses, duplexes, backyard cottages and mother-in-law units over garages, we are effectively denying housing to people mostly with lower incomes. That includes young families with children in our school district. In many cases, equitable housing choices could allow for kids to walk to their schools.”

Taking away from current homeowners the quiet enjoyment of backyard sunlight and privacy won’t solve the problems of poverty and lack of affordable housing—and misdirects attention from true causes (as scapegoating always misdirects attention from true causes and possibilities for systemic solutions).

Predictability is the social contract at the core of zoning laws—so a homeowner or prospective buyer knows whether a neighbor can build a factory, cattle ranch, or apartment building next door.

Detached accessory dwelling units can be great alternatives in new neighborhoods or neighborhoods zoned multifamily (and many of the single-family homes we see in Bellingham are actually within multifamily-zoned areas). But because predictability where one lives supports well-being, I oppose changing zoning in built-out neighborhoods currently zoned as single-family.

The social cohesion of Bellingham’s neighborhoods is precious, and quite a contrast to cities, towns, and especially bedroom communities where neighbors don’t know each other. We build this social fabric every day through block parties, neighborhood associations, front-yard gardening or porch-sitting, walking and bicycling, meeting in neighborhood parks, PTA and other family activities in our neighborhood schools, participating in soccer teams organized by neighborhood clusters, and emergency mapping projects—and through a commitment to care for each other because that’s how we want to live.

I’ve long pondered why Bellingham planners and city leaders push so hard to loosen accessory-dwelling-unit rules in built-out neighborhoods zoned single family, despite decades of neighborhood opposition. I have reluctantly concluded that their affordable-housing argument is a smokescreen for the actual motivation: By changing the rules, the City would solve its problem of long-standing failure to enforce current zoning for accessory dwelling units (even after the “grandfathering” exceptions enacted in the 1990s). I don’t think this benefit is worth tearing apart the social fabric of our neighborhoods.

Emily Weiner was active for many years in the Cornwall Park Neighborhood Association and Parkview Elementary School PTA, and wrote about development, education, and other topics for The Bellingham Herald and Cascadia Weekly. She now lives in the South Neighborhood.

Past Columns
Criminalizing Protest

July 18, 2018

Threshold Fund

June 13, 2018

Imprisoned Splendour

May 9, 2018

Pathways to Homeownership

April 25, 2018

Yes on I-1631

April 11, 2018

Schools and Planning for Growth

September 27, 2017

Electronic Home Monitoring

September 13, 2017

Boating Center Open

10:00am|Community Boating Center

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Bard on the Beach

12:00pm|Vanier Park

Northwest Raspberry Festival


Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Sin & Gin Tours

7:00pm|Downtown Bellingham, historic Fairhaven

Summer of Blood

7:00pm|Rexville Grange Amphitheater


9:00pm|Upfront Theatre

Raspberry Pancake Breakfast

7:00am|Lynden Community Center

Tour de Whatcom

7:30am|Boundary Bay Brewery

Ferndale Breakfast

8:00am|Ferndale Senior Center

Anacortes Farmers Market

9:00am|Depot Arts Center

Mount Vernon Farmers Market

9:00am|Riverwalk Park

Christmas in July Bazaar

9:00am|Bellingham Masonic Center

Twin Sisters Market

9:00am|Nugent's Corner, North Fork Library

Four Democrats seek election in the Skagit


Primary Election Forum

9:30am|Bellingham High School

NW Art Beat Studio Tour

10:00am|Skagit County

Blaine Gardeners Market

10:00am|H Street Plaza

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Summer Seersucker Bicycle Ride

10:00am|Gilkey Square

Lynden Farmers Market

10:00am|Centennial Park

Lummi Island Saturday Market

10:00am|Islander Grocery Store

Bellingham Farmers Market

10:00am| Depot Market Square

Correspondence Club

10:30am|Mindport Exhibits

Downtown Market Walk

11:00am|Downtown Bellingham

Street Food Saturdays

11:00am|Zuanich Point Park

Show & Shine

11:00am|BelleWood Acres

Hot Ticket

11:00am|North Fork Library

Public Sail

12:00pm|Cap Sante Marina

The Nandia Trilogy

1:00pm|Barnes & Noble


1:00pm|Point Roberts Library

Concrete Saturday Market

1:00pm|Concrete Community Center

Field Games

1:00pm|VanderYacht Park

Wren and Della

1:00pm|Blaine Library

Lynden Cemetery Tour

1:00pm|Lynden Cemetery

State Street History Tour

1:30pm|Depot Market Square

The Secret Garden

3:00pm|Mount Baker Theatre

Ferndale Uncorked and Uncapped

3:00pm|Centennial Riverwalk Park

Nooksack River Walk

3:00pm|Horseshoe Bend Trailhead

Whatcom Democrats Country Picnic

4:00pm|Hovander Homestead Park

Seafood Boil

5:30pm|Semiahmoo Resort

Seafood Boil

5:30pm|Semiahmoo Resort

Feast and Frolic

5:30pm|Viva Farms

Saturday Seafood Boil

5:30pm|Semiahmoo Resort

Music at Maritime

6:00pm|Maritime Heritage Park

Austin Jenckes

7:00pm|Eagle Haven Winery

Bellingham Youth Jazz Band

7:00pm|Bellingham Senior Activity Center

Sin & Gin Tours

7:00pm|Downtown Bellingham, historic Fairhaven

Nelson Mandela Tribute Concert

7:30pm|Bellingham Unitarian Fellowship

Bebel Gilberto

7:30pm| Lincoln Theatre

Gerrymandering Update

7:30pm|Island Library

Village Books
Boating Center Open

10:00am|Community Boating Center

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Bard on the Beach

12:00pm|Vanier Park

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Summer of Blood

7:00pm|Rexville Grange Amphitheater

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

NW Art Beat Studio Tour

10:00am|Skagit County

Sin & Gin Tours

7:00pm|Downtown Bellingham, historic Fairhaven

Rabbit Ride

8:00am|Fairhaven Bicycle

Vietnam Veterans Car Show

10:00am|Barkley Village

Edison Farmers Market

10:00am|Edison Granary

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Langar in Lynden

11:00am|Guru Nanak Gursikh Gurdwara

La Conner Live!

1:00pm|Gilkey Square

Skulls and Skins

1:00pm|Tennant Lake

Mosaic Stepping Stone Workshop

1:00pm|Chuckanut Center

Audubon at the Museum

1:30pm|Whatcom Museum's Old City Hall

Fiddlin' Fox Summer Concerts

2:00pm|Fairhaven Village Green

Trivia Time

3:30pm|Boundary Bay Brewery

Trivia Time

3:30pm|Boundary Bay Brewery

Village Books 2018 Cascadia Kids
Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Boating Center Open

10:00am|Community Boating Center

Bard on the Beach

12:00pm|Vanier Park

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Skagit Tours

10:00am|Highway 20

Rainbow Reads

12:00pm|Ferndale Library

Plant Diagnostic Clinics

5:00pm|Bellingham Public Library

Paddling Whatcom County


Cuban Salsa

6:00pm|Bell Tower Studios

Books on Tap Two

6:30pm|Tino's Pizza & Pasta Co.


9:00pm|Firefly Lounge

see our complete calendar »

Trove Web 2018 Cascadia Kids Cascadia Weekly Subscribe Ad 1 Village Books