The Gristle

Dueling Data

Wednesday, November 20, 2019

DUELING DATA: Bellingham’s Climate Action Task Force held its final public meeting this month, completing the remaining chapters of a report the citizen’s advisory group will present to Bellingham City Council in early December. Drawn from a broad range of professionals, the nine-member task force was created in 2018 with a mission to develop recommendations to help the achieve accelerated renewable energy targets, with specific focus on the financial, technological and societal challenges resulting from such a transition.

The report has not even been completed and presented to City Council, however, and it is already being dismantled and disseminated in highly misleading mailers from building industry and carbon energy operatives.

Talk about trying to derail the train before it even leaves the station!

The Clean Energy Transformation Act (CETA) passed last session by the state Legislature creates a pathway toward a 100 percent carbon-free electrical grid in the state of Washington by 2045. The City of Bellingham proposes aggressive carbon-reduction targets by 2030.

The Building Industry Association of Whatcom County plans a luncheon this week to push back on those targets by releasing a highly dubious forecast of the cost of those transitions on local homeowners.  Those forecasts were included in a widely circulated mailer created by the BIA, Cascade Natural Gas, The Association of General Contractors, and the Whatcom County Association of Realtors that projected those costs as between $36,050 and $82,750 for a typical Bellingham home.

“For every $1,000 increase in the cost of a home, 113 local families are priced out of the market and cannot realize the American Dream of Homeownership. This conversion will price 4,068 to 9,266+ households out of the Bellingham housing market,” building industry lobbyists wailed in their flier that went out to thousands of Bellingham addresses earlier this month.

These are preposterous numbers, and not at all what the task force has projected or proposed.

“They have provided no citations for their cost data sources and no description of the methodology they used to derive their numbers,” observed Erin McDade, an expert who specializes in energy retrofits and decarbonized new construction. She serves on the task force. “Members of the task force have reached out multiple times to both Jacquelyn Styrna from BIAWC and Alyn Spector from CNG asking for details on their cost data sources and assumptions. Every request has been ignored,” McDade said.

In her own analysis constructed from cited sources, McDade estimated the conversion cost for a typical home would be on the order of $500 to $11,500, without the financing options the task force will propose. The energy savings of those retrofits over 20 years, she estimated, would be between $8,000 and $12,600 for a typical family home. Twenty years is the approximate expected life of space and water heating equipment in the average home, which mean these conversions can be coordinated with the anticipated replacement costs associated with homeownership.

“They have listed costs for things that would never be required for conversion from natural gas to electricity,” she noted. “Multiple HVAC and engineering professionals within Bellingham confirmed for the task force that no costs for these items would ever be associated with conversion.”

“Every iteration of the BIA and GNC contractors’ numbers appear to be inflated about four to five times the amount estimated by the task force,” Mark Gardner observed. Gardner is City Council’s legislative researcher who has worked with the task force to gather comparable numbers from other municipalities.

His research and that of the task force included energy conversion studies from California. The team recommends a comparable study for Bellingham and the Puget Sound region.

“Research and discussion with the industry experts who each pointed us to these studies indicates that the costs are likely to be even more favorable in Washington as equipment and electricity costs are typically lower here,” McDade commented.

“The leading paragraph of the flier states that the mission of the task force is to determine the ‘feasibility, costs, and impacts of the City’s 100 percent renewable energy ambitions.’ While true, this statement leaves out the other pieces of the task force mandate,” McDade noted, which are to establish feasible, non-disruptive energy targets, as well as identify funding mechanisms and develop a plan to achieve the Task Force’s recommended targets. Their document will identify policy considerations that may help Bellingham attain accelerated targets.

McDade helped create a flyer similar in appearance to the deceptive BIA mailer that puts more realistic numbers into perspective and provides actual sources for the data.

“In order to provide a more accurate breakdown of what conversion from natural gas to electricity might look like for a typical home, task force members consulted what industry experts collectively agree are the best available sources of such cost information,” McDade explained. Those sources will be included in the report they will present to Council.

Perhaps the most salient takeaway from the “dueling data” is that none of it has even been formally presented to city policymakers. This is the well-financed energy industry—fueled by dark cash from groups like CNG and Phillips66—working in tandem with the construction industry to smother climate change policy in its crib. These same groups were mercilessly at work to hijack recent local elections.

“How much money has this cohort has spent on the mailers, phone surveys, and door-knocking campaigns they’ve used to disseminate this information?” McDade wondered. “Costs incurred by utilities are typically passed on to their customers. Are CNG customers going to see any rate increases to offset the cost of this campaign?”

Let’s never forget that inaction on climate change also carries a cost.

Past Columns
Grand Slam

May 12, 2021

Carbon Pricing Reality

April 28, 2021

Third Time’s A Charm

April 14, 2021

Salmon Need Water

March 31, 2021

Mid-Point

March 17, 2021

Carbon Pricing

March 3, 2021

‘Stop The Steal’

February 17, 2021

Camp 210

February 3, 2021

A capricious flower

January 20, 2021

‘More Work To Do’

January 6, 2021

Pathways for Pathogens

December 23, 2020

Make A Difference

December 9, 2020

Down to the Wire

November 25, 2020

Blue Wave 2020

November 11, 2020

Dark Deeds

October 28, 2020

Fire and Water

October 14, 2020

Defining Family

September 30, 2020

Smoke and Acrimony

September 16, 2020

Housing Saves Lives

September 2, 2020

Increments

August 19, 2020

Thursday
An Artist's Universe at Hotel Bellwether

9:00am

View painter and mixed-media master David Syre’s latest installation, “An Artist’s Universe,” hanging throughout the corridors, lobby and dining room of Hotel Bellwether and the Lighthouse…

Fragile Ecology

11:00am

Painter Clayton Marsh’s one-man show, “Fragile Ecology: Land. People. Harmonies,” can be seen from 11am-6pm daily through May (closed Tuesdays) in Mount Vernon at Perry and Carlson Gallery,…

An Artist's Universe at Hotel Bellwether

9:00am

View painter and mixed-media master David Syre’s latest installation, “An Artist’s Universe,” hanging throughout the corridors, lobby and dining room of Hotel Bellwether and the Lighthouse…

Fragile Ecology

11:00am

Painter Clayton Marsh’s one-man show, “Fragile Ecology: Land. People. Harmonies,” can be seen from 11am-6pm daily through May (closed Tuesdays) in Mount Vernon at Perry and Carlson Gallery,…

Whatcom Art Market

11:00am

Works by as many as 45 Whatcom Art Guild members can be viewed from 11am-5pm Tuesdays through Sundays at Whatcom Art Market, 1103 11th St.

An Artist's Universe at Hotel Bellwether

9:00am

View painter and mixed-media master David Syre’s latest installation, “An Artist’s Universe,” hanging throughout the corridors, lobby and dining room of Hotel Bellwether and the Lighthouse…

Fragile Ecology

11:00am

Painter Clayton Marsh’s one-man show, “Fragile Ecology: Land. People. Harmonies,” can be seen from 11am-6pm daily through May (closed Tuesdays) in Mount Vernon at Perry and Carlson Gallery,…

Whatcom Art Market

11:00am

Works by as many as 45 Whatcom Art Guild members can be viewed from 11am-5pm Tuesdays through Sundays at Whatcom Art Market, 1103 11th St.

Whatcom Art Market

11:00am

Works by as many as 45 Whatcom Art Guild members can be viewed from 11am-5pm Tuesdays through Sundays at Whatcom Art Market, 1103 11th St.

Origins and Evolutions Exhibit

11:00am

“Origins and Evolutions: Five Generations” can be seen from 11am-4pm Tues.-Thurs., and by appointment, at least through May 22 at Gallery Syre, 465 Stuart Rd. The show gathers together…

Spring Into Art

11:00am

View works by Stanwood-Camano Arts Guild members from 11am-5pm Wed.-Sat. in Stanwood at A Guilded Gallery, 8700 271st St. NW. A “Spring Into Art” regional juried art show can be seen through…

Whatcom Art Market

11:00am

Works by as many as 45 Whatcom Art Guild members can be viewed from 11am-5pm Tuesdays through Sundays at Whatcom Art Market, 1103 11th St.

Leo Osborne at Scott Milo Gallery

11:00am

Painter and sculptor Leo Osborne’s works will be featured from 11am-5pm Wednesdays through Sundays through May in Anacortes at the Scott Milo Gallery, 420 Commercial Ave. Osborne presents his…

Origins and Evolutions Exhibit

11:00am

“Origins and Evolutions: Five Generations” can be seen from 11am-4pm Tues.-Thurs., and by appointment, at least through May 22 at Gallery Syre, 465 Stuart Rd. The show gathers together…

Irene Dawson at Good Earth Pottery

11:00am

Works by Irene Dawson will be featured from 11am-5pm from 11am-5pm Mondays through Saturdays (closed Tuesdays) and 11am-4pm Sundays through May at Good Earth Pottery, 1000 Harris Ave. Ten…

Teen Events with WCLS

3:00pm

Students in grades 6 to 12 can sign up for a variety of virtual events through Whatcom County Library System, including “Teen Reads” from 3pm-4pm Wednesdays, “Whatcom Teen Writers” from…

Leo Osborne at Scott Milo Gallery

11:00am

Painter and sculptor Leo Osborne’s works will be featured from 11am-5pm Wednesdays through Sundays through May in Anacortes at the Scott Milo Gallery, 420 Commercial Ave. Osborne presents his…

Origins and Evolutions Exhibit

11:00am

“Origins and Evolutions: Five Generations” can be seen from 11am-4pm Tues.-Thurs., and by appointment, at least through May 22 at Gallery Syre, 465 Stuart Rd. The show gathers together…

Whatcom Art Market

11:00am

Works by as many as 45 Whatcom Art Guild members can be viewed from 11am-5pm Tuesdays through Sundays at Whatcom Art Market, 1103 11th St.

Spring Into Art

11:00am

View works by Stanwood-Camano Arts Guild members from 11am-5pm Wed.-Sat. in Stanwood at A Guilded Gallery, 8700 271st St. NW. A “Spring Into Art” regional juried art show can be seen through…

Seeds of Culture at Whatcom Museum

12:00pm

View “Seeds of Culture: The Portraits and Voices of Native American Women,” “Fluid Formations: The Legacy of Glass in the Pacific Northwest,” “Jac Trautman: The Specter of the Indigenous,”…

Spring Juried Exhibit and More

12:00pm

A “Spring Juried Exhibit,” “Winter Textile Explorations,” Lisa McShane’s “A Decade of Landscapes,” and Ron Pattern’s “The Seasonal Forest” can be viewed from 12pm-4:30pm Thursdays through…

Cascadia International Women's Film Festival

12:00pm

The fifth annual CASCADIA International Women’s Film Festival takes place from May 13-22 online. Twenty-seven films from around the world will bring to light the work of both emerging and…

Food Bank Distribution

1:00pm

Bellingham Food Bank distributes pre-packed food boxes from 1pm-4pm Thursdays at 1175 Jersey St. People can join a car queue and, when it’s their turn, volunteers will offer food boxes…

Bark Steward Party

5:30pm

If your dog loves going to the park, and you want to help take care of local parks and trails with your pooch, show your love by joining Bellingham Parks and Rec for a “Bark Steward Party”…

Friday
An Artist's Universe at Hotel Bellwether

9:00am

View painter and mixed-media master David Syre’s latest installation, “An Artist’s Universe,” hanging throughout the corridors, lobby and dining room of Hotel Bellwether and the Lighthouse…

Fragile Ecology

11:00am

Painter Clayton Marsh’s one-man show, “Fragile Ecology: Land. People. Harmonies,” can be seen from 11am-6pm daily through May (closed Tuesdays) in Mount Vernon at Perry and Carlson Gallery,…

An Artist's Universe at Hotel Bellwether

9:00am

View painter and mixed-media master David Syre’s latest installation, “An Artist’s Universe,” hanging throughout the corridors, lobby and dining room of Hotel Bellwether and the Lighthouse…

Fragile Ecology

11:00am

Painter Clayton Marsh’s one-man show, “Fragile Ecology: Land. People. Harmonies,” can be seen from 11am-6pm daily through May (closed Tuesdays) in Mount Vernon at Perry and Carlson Gallery,…

Whatcom Art Market

11:00am

Works by as many as 45 Whatcom Art Guild members can be viewed from 11am-5pm Tuesdays through Sundays at Whatcom Art Market, 1103 11th St.

An Artist's Universe at Hotel Bellwether

9:00am

View painter and mixed-media master David Syre’s latest installation, “An Artist’s Universe,” hanging throughout the corridors, lobby and dining room of Hotel Bellwether and the Lighthouse…

Fragile Ecology

11:00am

Painter Clayton Marsh’s one-man show, “Fragile Ecology: Land. People. Harmonies,” can be seen from 11am-6pm daily through May (closed Tuesdays) in Mount Vernon at Perry and Carlson Gallery,…

Whatcom Art Market

11:00am

Works by as many as 45 Whatcom Art Guild members can be viewed from 11am-5pm Tuesdays through Sundays at Whatcom Art Market, 1103 11th St.

Whatcom Art Market

11:00am

Works by as many as 45 Whatcom Art Guild members can be viewed from 11am-5pm Tuesdays through Sundays at Whatcom Art Market, 1103 11th St.

Origins and Evolutions Exhibit

11:00am

“Origins and Evolutions: Five Generations” can be seen from 11am-4pm Tues.-Thurs., and by appointment, at least through May 22 at Gallery Syre, 465 Stuart Rd. The show gathers together…

Spring Into Art

11:00am

View works by Stanwood-Camano Arts Guild members from 11am-5pm Wed.-Sat. in Stanwood at A Guilded Gallery, 8700 271st St. NW. A “Spring Into Art” regional juried art show can be seen through…

Whatcom Art Market

11:00am

Works by as many as 45 Whatcom Art Guild members can be viewed from 11am-5pm Tuesdays through Sundays at Whatcom Art Market, 1103 11th St.

Leo Osborne at Scott Milo Gallery

11:00am

Painter and sculptor Leo Osborne’s works will be featured from 11am-5pm Wednesdays through Sundays through May in Anacortes at the Scott Milo Gallery, 420 Commercial Ave. Osborne presents his…

Origins and Evolutions Exhibit

11:00am

“Origins and Evolutions: Five Generations” can be seen from 11am-4pm Tues.-Thurs., and by appointment, at least through May 22 at Gallery Syre, 465 Stuart Rd. The show gathers together…

Irene Dawson at Good Earth Pottery

11:00am

Works by Irene Dawson will be featured from 11am-5pm from 11am-5pm Mondays through Saturdays (closed Tuesdays) and 11am-4pm Sundays through May at Good Earth Pottery, 1000 Harris Ave. Ten…

Teen Events with WCLS

3:00pm

Students in grades 6 to 12 can sign up for a variety of virtual events through Whatcom County Library System, including “Teen Reads” from 3pm-4pm Wednesdays, “Whatcom Teen Writers” from…

Leo Osborne at Scott Milo Gallery

11:00am

Painter and sculptor Leo Osborne’s works will be featured from 11am-5pm Wednesdays through Sundays through May in Anacortes at the Scott Milo Gallery, 420 Commercial Ave. Osborne presents his…

Origins and Evolutions Exhibit

11:00am

“Origins and Evolutions: Five Generations” can be seen from 11am-4pm Tues.-Thurs., and by appointment, at least through May 22 at Gallery Syre, 465 Stuart Rd. The show gathers together…

Whatcom Art Market

11:00am

Works by as many as 45 Whatcom Art Guild members can be viewed from 11am-5pm Tuesdays through Sundays at Whatcom Art Market, 1103 11th St.

Spring Into Art

11:00am

View works by Stanwood-Camano Arts Guild members from 11am-5pm Wed.-Sat. in Stanwood at A Guilded Gallery, 8700 271st St. NW. A “Spring Into Art” regional juried art show can be seen through…

Seeds of Culture at Whatcom Museum

12:00pm

View “Seeds of Culture: The Portraits and Voices of Native American Women,” “Fluid Formations: The Legacy of Glass in the Pacific Northwest,” “Jac Trautman: The Specter of the Indigenous,”…

Spring Juried Exhibit and More

12:00pm

A “Spring Juried Exhibit,” “Winter Textile Explorations,” Lisa McShane’s “A Decade of Landscapes,” and Ron Pattern’s “The Seasonal Forest” can be viewed from 12pm-4:30pm Thursdays through…

Cascadia International Women's Film Festival

12:00pm

The fifth annual CASCADIA International Women’s Film Festival takes place from May 13-22 online. Twenty-seven films from around the world will bring to light the work of both emerging and…

Food Bank Distribution

1:00pm

Bellingham Food Bank distributes pre-packed food boxes from 1pm-4pm Thursdays at 1175 Jersey St. People can join a car queue and, when it’s their turn, volunteers will offer food boxes…

Bark Steward Party

5:30pm

If your dog loves going to the park, and you want to help take care of local parks and trails with your pooch, show your love by joining Bellingham Parks and Rec for a “Bark Steward Party”…